Week 16 – All on the Line

This is it. It’s championship week in most leagues, and if your team is going to win the Super Bowl, it’s going to take some smart moves when it comes to who to start and who to sit. We thought we would go simple and just offer our thoughts on some start/sit decisions that could mean the difference when everything is on the line. Besides the obvious plays, here are our thoughts:

QBs
Start ‘Em:

Tony Romo, DAL – The Cowboys need to win to stay alive, and despite shutting out Tampa Bay last week, the Saints’ D is historically bad.

Andrew Luck – The rookie has a juicy matchup against the abysmal Kansas City Chiefs.

Colin Kaepernick, SF – The Niners’ QB moving forward has been playing really well and is a constant threat to run. Even against a stout Seahawks’ Defense, he has the skill set to produce every week.

Colin Kaepernick Keeps Proving Himself a Viable QB1.

Sit ‘Em:

Eli Manning, NYG – Eli has been frustrating owners for the past several weeks.

Matt Stafford, DET – It is hard to trust Stafford with his limited options besides Megatron. The Falcons will be looking to make another statement Saturday night.

Joe Flacco, BAL – Flacco’s critics have been validated as of late. He has shown an inability to achieve any kind of consistency. Keep him off the roster in the championship matchup.

Playing Eli Manning Carries a High Risk of Late

WRs
Start ‘Em:

Randall Cobb, GB – Quietly had his second straight 100-yard outing, and the Titans’ secondary is suspect.

Pierre Garcon, WAS – Whether it’s RG3 or KC1, he is the Skins’ top target.

Cecil Shorts, JAX – Didn’t miss a beat coming back from his concussion. The Patriots have allowed 270.3 passing YPG.

Sit ‘Em:

Jeremy Maclin, PHI – Has been hot lately, but that likely ends Sunday against a hungry Washington team.

Larry Fitzgerald, ARI – Nobody thought we’d be saying this, but without a real QB and against a solid Bears defense, there’s not much upside.

Torrey Smith, BAL – Don’t be too eager slotting Smith back in following his concussion if he plays – he had just one catch on 3 targets before getting hurt in the third quarter.

RBs
Start ‘Em:

Vick Ballard, IND – Ballard has come on lately, establishing himself as a consistent producer, and the KC defense doesn’t seem capable of shutting down anybody.

DeAngelo Williams, CAR– With Jonathan Stewart out the past two weeks with a high ankle sprain, Williams has been getting the job done nicely, and has the potential to break out with big plays at any moment in a game.

Stevan Ridley, NE – Ridley’s poor performance against the 49ers gets avenged in garbage time against lowly Jacksonville.

Sit ‘Em:

Michael Turner, ATL – Looking past his scores in 5 straight games, the Burner is averaging just 42.4 YPG. Risky.

Shonn Greene, NYJ – He’s steady enough of a performer, but Bilal Powell’s work has diminished his value greatly.

BenJarvus Green-Ellis – The Law Firm has had a hot streak, but Pittsburgh’s run defense is among the best in the league. The Bengals will have to play in the air to win.

TEs
Start ‘Em:

Jermaine Gresham, CIN – The Steelers will be looking to shut down Andy Dalton’s biggest weapon in A.J. Green, opening the door for the big man Gresham to get plenty of looks.

Heath Miller, PIT – Averaging 85 yards in the last 3 games with two TDs to show for it. Miller played a big role in the Steelers’ first meeting with Cincinnati this season.

Greg Olsen, CAR – Oakland has allowed plenty of tight end touchdowns this season. Olsen is a favorite Cam Newton target, with 747 yards on the year.

Sit ‘Em:

Dennis Pitta, BAL – His stock has never been higher, but it’s just not likely to see a repeat performance of Week 15 against a desperate Giants squad.

Vernon Davis, SF – He just missed a beautiful TD pass against New England, but Davis has gone virtually invisible the second half of this season.

scoutPRO wishes all the GMs competing for league titles the best of luck, and make sure to brag about your victory to us on Twitter at @csascoutpro !

Catching Up with scoutPRO Fantasy Expert Nelson Sousa

This week, we had a chance to sit down with scoutPRO’s resident expert Nelson “The Franchise” Sousa about what it is like competing at the highest levels of Fantasy Football. Fresh off participating in a high-stakes draft for the National Fantasy Football Championship (NFFC) at the Bellagio Hotel in Las Vegas, Nelson offered some insights on this year’s Fantasy trends, the approaches and strategies of top tier fantasy GMs, and his efforts to help answer owners’ toughest start/sit questions through scoutPRO’s weekly ‘Ask Nelson’ feature.

scoutPRO: You just spent a weekend drafting a roster against some of the most knowledgeable, experienced fantasy football players in the world. Can you tell us a little about the different draft strategies you saw in Vegas for this season?

Nelson: This year, I saw three pretty distinct strategies. First, there was a group focused on snatching up the elite quarterbacks. There are just a handful of guys at the very top of the game at the QB position – Rodgers, Brady, Brees… they play on teams that really emphasize the passing game, and they are bound to rack up points all season long. The second group recognized that the pool of Running Backs who should really contribute something this special is pretty thin; a lot of teams operate their running game by committee now, and run defenses are more intimidating than ever before. Focus on picking up the Arian Fosters, the Ray Rices, was pretty intense. Some of the players approached their ground game by ‘handcuffing,’ where you take multiple guys on a team that runs by committee to pick up credit on every down they play, or have a good backup plan in case one gets hurt. I personally fall into the third camp, where I follow the flow of the draft to try and get the best player available. Obviously I stay conscious of constructing a solid structure top-to-bottom for my team, but every draft is fluid, and I am comfortable focusing on getting the right guy in each round – I am looking for the talent that will make my roster deeper across the board.

scoutPRO: Are there any new or emergent trends you have seen in the NFL that have shaped the way fantasy owners think about roster construction and management?

Nelson: There are two that come to mind. First off, rookies are really making a big impact in fantasy football now. In years past, guys would come into the NFL and coaches wouldn’t really invest their full trust in the young guns. The progression used to be visible from a bench player, to maybe getting some looks on special teams, and slowly working your way into a role with the team. Nowadays, teams are asking guys like RG3 and Trent Richardson to come in and step into huge roles. We have real playmaking rookies who have shown that they can compete at the highest levels.  It really changes the game for fantasy owners, because they are unproven, but drafting them can pay huge dividends.

Also, the emergence of the Tight End as a more valuable position has definitely changed the look of the average fantasy draft. For me, it all started in 2008 when the Patriots had Randy Moss and Wes Welker catching balls all over the field. Defenses became so focused on WR coverage that entering the 2010 season, Bill Belichick decided to change the game up and draft two stud tight ends in Rob Gronkowski and Aaron Hernandez not only to open up the field for WRs, but to catch tons of passes themselves. They have thrived because the passing game is much wider open with tight ends on the field. The NFL is a copycat league, so other teams found success in giving tight ends a chance to contribute as well. Now guys like Jimmy Graham and Vernon Davis can be serious fantasy point producers week in and week out.

scoutPRO: In our weekly ‘Ask Nelson’ feature, our subscribers get the chance to get your opinion on who to start and sit, advice on trades, and answers to their other fantasy questions. In Week 1, you foresaw that Tony Romo would be a better start than Philip Rivers against the Raiders, even though he struggled in the preseason and was up against a much better Giants defense. Your advice paid off. How do you find so much success in understanding the game and making smart predictions?

Really, my approach to making tough calls like that one is just based in watching games. I always approach fantasy football from a scouting perspective, rather than mulling over table after table of meaningless numbers. There is nothing an owner can do to learn more about the players than to watch them play. On Sundays, that means sitting down and watching games. Then, watching more games replayed either on TV or online. I always take the time to see what is happening. That way, when the time comes to make a call, I draw on my real knowledge. I knew that Rivers, in this case, was without the threat of injured Ryan Mathews, putting additional pressure on the pass game, and that Romo has real chemistry with the weapons on his team. Poor preseason aside, the call was clear. There is always some fortune involved in whether it turns out well, but I trust that scouting to help make the most educated guess.

Check back for part 2 of our interview next week to hear Nelson’s thoughts on week-to-week roster management, statistical analysis, and Super Bowl predictions. 

Preseason Week 2 – Vital Info for Your Draft

scoutPRO has been busy watching all of the preseason Week 2 action unfold, and keeping our eyes on some players to watch or avoid as fantasy owners prepare to draft their 2012 rosters. Here are some of the most interesting developments from the weekend:

Michael Turner looks extremely slow. He has been ineffective in the first two weeks of the preseason, and with Matt Ryan making plenty of throws targeting Roddy White and Julio Jones, expectations for Turner are even lower.

It is still unclear whether the Bills will be able to live up to the lofty standard they set during last year’s surprise season. Fred Jackson and CJ Spiller both have had little success on the ground in the first two exhibitions, and behind Stevie Johnson, the boys from Buffalo are lacking much depth at WR, save for perhaps Donald Jones. These guys will need to be much better to merit roster spots, especially in less deep leagues.

Will this finally be the year the Raiders break 2 years stuck at the 8-8 plateau for a winning season? Darren McFadden is making a case for consideration among the elite RBs of the league, and he has been targeted with a number of screen and short passes in the current offense. Darius Heyward-Bey may fall down the draft board a bit after looking a bit untidy so far this preseason, but he will be a serious value at WR to owners who pick him up.

Darren McFadden could surprise this year

They still feature one of the league’s most intimidating defenses, but the Jets just can’t seem to get things together on the offensive side of the ball. Mark Sanchez went 9-11 in the second preseason game, but it wasn’t pretty. None of the team’s WR corps, save for perhaps the injured Santonio Holmes (who should be ready to go for Week 1), appear to be at a high enough level to earn a roster spot.Shonn Greene looks disoriented, running into his own lineman on several occasions this past week. Buyer beware; this offense is shaky at best.

The Cowboys have shown some interesting tricks in their first pair of preseason matchups that should grab the attention of fantasy owners everywhere. Dez Bryant has been a beast – but he is somewhat fragile (reports that he hurt his knee again in practice Monday are another red flag for owners). If he can stay healthy, he will absolutely be a top flight WR. Tony Romo’s athleticism has helped him maintain his status as one of the best QB options outside of the few elite guys at the top. Assuming Miles Austin is ready to go for Week 1, he should be ready to rock and roll to duplicate his great 2011 season.

scoutPRO fantasy expert Nelson Sousa’s full report on what he saw is available for members on www.scoutpro.com. Check it out today!

Tight End Frenzy

Last season, the Patriots’ Rob Gronkowski led a class of tight ends that revitalized the position’s role in many teams’ offensive schemes as he set a new NFL record for touchdown receptions by a TE with 14. His numbers made him not only the top ranking player at his position, but put him right there near the top of the list of all receivers in fantasy leagues.

If you aren’t fortunate enough to snatch Gronk in this year’s draft, there are plenty of other great options in the strong group that will be on display in the 2012 season:

Aaron Hernandez is the dynamic other half of the Patriots impressive dual-tight end look. Hernandez provided Tom Brady with another great option in addition to Gronkowski and the dependable Wes Welker. Of course, his value is diminished a bit by having to share the spotlight, but he is still sure to have ample opportunity to deliver big plays for the Pats.

Jimmy Graham leads all TEs in receptions, racking up more than 1,300 receiving yards and scoring 11 TDs in 2011. If it weren’t for Gronkowski, he would be the clear cut #1 TE for this year’s fantasy rankings. He still may end up being the best if he manages to maintain his high level game, especially with Robert Meachem gone.

Jason Witten had a mediocre campaign last season, coming up short up 1,000 receiving yards and only 5 TDs. He is more talented than he sometimes gets credit for, and is still one of the more durable options in this category, having started every game for the last five seasons. Also, Tony Romo loves him. Like every year, the optimism for Dallas is high, and so it should be for Witten too. He will be a solid contributor.

Jermichael Finley was plagued by dropped-ball syndrome and hurt by the emergence of Jordy Nelson last season.  Going into 2012, those problems will spark doubts, but there should be no questions about his awesome skill set. Finley is looking for a bounceback season, and he may break out since he is now reached the magical point of a full season removed from his knee injury.

Not So Obvious

This week’s blog takes a look at a few players, some likely and others less so, who could break out as the top performer in their respective position this upcoming fantasy season:

QB: Tom Brady – Many experts are pegging Aaron Rodgers ahead of Brady as the #1 in the game’s most prolific position. Some may even select Drew Brees and Cam Newton higher than the two-time super bowl MVP. The Patriots look to be a powerhouse on the offensive side of the ball again in 2012, adding a deep threat in Brandon Lloyd and bringing Josh McDaniels back as the Offensive Coordinator. Couple that with the resigning of ultra-reliable Wes Welker and the emergence of Rob Gronkowski as one of the game’s premier TEs, and Brady could end up running away from the competition as the #1 QB this year.

RB: Ryan Mathews – He has only been in the league for two years, but despite not playing a full 16 games in either season, it feels like Mathews has gained the experience necessary to become an elite RB in any fantasy league. In the past, he was somewhat limited on carries, making his first 1,000 yard season very impressive. This year, Mike Tolbert has been shipped out, putting the spotlight directly on Mathews. Pair his natural talent with Robert Meachem, arguably the best run-blocking WR and the newly signed FB Le’Ron McClain, and the Chargers fans may be reminded of the kind of running game they enjoyed in the days of Ladanian Tomlinson’s tenure in southern California.

WR: Dez Bryant – While it is hard to imagine anyone leapfrogging Megatron as the #1 WR this year, Bryant, entering his third season, is primed to explode. While opponents facing Calvin Johnson now have adjusted and will be highly focused on containing him, Bryant, following his first full healthy offseason working closely with Tony Romo, enjoys the company of Miles Austin to distract defenses. He definitely has the complete skill set; if he puts it all together he could be the best WR contributor this year.

TE: Vernon Davis – The aforementioned Gronk and Jimmy Graham are the likely #1 and 2 in either order on paper, but VD is just as much a physical freak and will have a chance to really thrive this year.  Adapting well to Jim Harbaugh’s blue collar offense that elevates the role of the TE, Davis came on strong late in the year last season. Now, having future Hall of Famer Randy Moss and the dynamic Mario Manningham outside will allow plenty of room for Davis to work the middle, opening up the 49ers offense for big plays through the highly athletic TE.